Knowledge Center

This is an appeal from an interlocutory decision obliging the Appellant, Optimum Insurance Company, to defend its insured and pay the cost of independent counsel in an action arising from a motor vehicle accident. The appellant insurer sought a stay of the matter pending the outcome of another matter deciding the same issues. The court upheld the lower court finding that there was a duty to defend, regardless of whether there were parallel proceedings and refused to grant a stay.

June 24, 2004

Drane v. Optimum Frontier Insurance Co., [2004] N.B.J. No. 251, New Brunswick Court of Appeal

The Plaintiff, Mr. Drane, was one of the occupants of a motor vehicle that was involved in a single motor vehicle accident. He commenced an action against the named insured of the vehicle, and another occupant who Mr. Drane alleged was the driver. Another of the occupants commenced an action against Mr. Drane, alleging that Mr. Drane was the driver and that he was impaired at the time of the accident.

Optimum commenced a third action against Mr. Drane, seeking a declaration that there was neither a duty to indemnify nor to defend Mr. Drane, because he was driving impaired at the time of the accident, and in fact owned the truck at issue. Other grounds for those proceedings included an allegation that material misrepresentations as to the actual ownership of the truck were made during the process of applying for insurance.

The subject matter of this appeal was a fourth originating process, an application by Mr. Drane seeking a declaratory order that Optimum had a duty to defend and indemnify. The applications judge rejected Optimum’s request for a stay of the application until the other actions dealing with the issues could be decided, and ordered Optimum to indemnify Mr. Drane.

The appeal court held that there was insufficient information available to the applications court such that the questions pertaining to the alleged breaches of the policy terms or statutory conditions could be adjudicated upon summarily, and Optimum could have brought a motion to have the question of the duty to defend resolved on the evidence. The appeal was dismissed with costs to Mr. Drane.

To stay current with the new case law and emerging legal issues in this area, subscribe here.

Tags

Important Notice: The information contained in this Article is intended for general information purposes only and does not create a lawyer-client relationship. It is not intended as legal advice from Harper Grey LLP or the individual author(s), nor intended as a substitute for legal advice on any specific subject matter. Detailed legal counsel should be sought prior to undertaking any legal matter. The information contained in this Article is current to the last update and may change. Last Update: January 16, 2024.

Related

Monique Sever participated in International Legal Technology Association’s video titled “Diversity in eDiscovery: It’s No Longer a Man’s World”
Monique Sever participated in International Legal Technology Association’s video titled “Diversity in eDiscovery: It’s No Longer a Man’s World” Monique Sever participated in International Legal Technology Association’s video titled “Diversity in eDiscovery: It’s No Longer a Man’s World”
An individual board member may disclose confidential board information to their own lawyer on matters affecting them personally
An individual board member may disclose confidential board information to their own lawyer on matters affecting them personally An individual board member may disclose confidential board information to their own lawyer on matters affecting them personally
Rose Keith, KC authors quarterly Mediation Moment Column for Spring 2024 Edition of The Verdict
Rose Keith, KC authors quarterly Mediation Moment Column for Spring 2024 Edition of The Verdict Rose Keith, KC authors quarterly Mediation Moment Column for Spring 2024 Edition of The Verdict
Dan Reid interviewed by Law360 in article titled “B.C. strengthens information-sharing protections in child welfare legislation after court decision”
Dan Reid interviewed by Law360 in article titled “B.C. strengthens information-sharing protections in child welfare legislation after court decision” Dan Reid interviewed by Law360 in article titled “B.C. strengthens information-sharing protections in child welfare legislation after court decision”
Harper Grey proudly sponsors The Lawyer Show
Harper Grey proudly sponsors The Lawyer Show Harper Grey proudly sponsors The Lawyer Show Harper Grey proudly sponsors The Lawyer Show
Drew Lawrenson and Arjun Dhaliwal to attend NABOC Vancouver Conference
Drew Lawrenson and Arjun Dhaliwal to attend NABOC Vancouver Conference Drew Lawrenson and Arjun Dhaliwal to attend NABOC Vancouver Conference Drew Lawrenson and Arjun Dhaliwal to attend NABOC Vancouver Conference
Leyla Salmi to attend UBC’s 2024 Spring Graduation Ceremony as Science Alumni Representative
Leyla Salmi to attend UBC’s 2024 Spring Graduation Ceremony as Science Alumni Representative Leyla Salmi to attend UBC’s 2024 Spring Graduation Ceremony as Science Alumni Representative
Norm Streu discusses understanding the legal obligations of confidentiality with Business In Vancouver
Norm Streu discusses understanding the legal obligations of confidentiality with Business In Vancouver Norm Streu discusses understanding the legal obligations of confidentiality with Business In Vancouver
Articling student Zheng-Yi Ong attends 17th Annual FACL Ontario Conference and Gala
Articling student Zheng-Yi Ong attends 17th Annual FACL Ontario Conference and Gala Articling student Zheng-Yi Ong attends 17th Annual FACL Ontario Conference and Gala
Rachel Wood joins Harper Grey as an Associate
Rachel Wood joins Harper Grey as an Associate Rachel Wood joins Harper Grey as an Associate
Harper Grey to host Empowering Female Entrepreneurs: Business Basics Webinar
Harper Grey to host Empowering Female Entrepreneurs: Business Basics Webinar
Harper Grey Professional Regulation Group recognized as “Consistently Recommended” by 2024 Canadian Legal Lexpert Directory
Harper Grey Professional Regulation Group recognized as “Consistently Recommended” by 2024 Canadian Legal Lexpert Directory
2024 Kathy O’Donovan Award of Excellence
2024 Kathy O’Donovan Award of Excellence
TAG Alliances published article authored by Norm Streu
TAG Alliances published article authored by Norm Streu TAG Alliances published article authored by Norm Streu
Harper Grey continues to support West Coast LEAF Through Supporter Sponsorship of 2024 Equity Breakfast
Harper Grey continues to support West Coast LEAF Through Supporter Sponsorship of 2024 Equity Breakfast
arrow icon

Subscribe