Knowledge Center

The applicant was not an “office holder” and therefore his dismissal by the respondent was subject to a minimal duty of fairness which was met by the respondent in the circumstances

January 25, 2005

Administrative law – Employment law – Termination of employment – Judicial review – Procedural requirements and fairness – Bias

Youth Criminal Defence Office v. Board of Directors of the Legal Aid Society of Alberta, [2004] A.J. No. 1345, November 3, 2004, Alberta Court of Queen’s Bench, Hart J.

The applicant (“Holtby”) applied for a declaration of nullity and an order in the nature of certiorari quashing the decision of the respondent Board of Directors of the Legal Aid Society (the “Board”) to terminate his employment as Senior Counsel of the Youth Criminal Defence Office. Amongst other things, Holtby submitted that the Board breached its duty of fairness and that the circumstances behind his dismissal gave rise to a reasonable apprehension of bias.

Holtby submitted that a duty of fairness can arise as a term of an employee contract or where an employee is the holder of an office in which the public has an interest.

The Court held that although Holtby was in a position of considerable responsibility in which the public had an interest, the link between his position and any statute was tenuous. He was subject to Board control and there was an absence of governmental representation on the Board. The Court therefore held that the applicant was not an office holder.

In determining the content of the duty of fairness in the situation, the Court noted the contextual approach which called for a consideration of the following:

  1. The nature of the decision being made and the process being followed in making it;
  2. The nature of the statutory scheme and the terms of the statute pursuant to which the body operates;
  3. The importance of the decision to the individual or individuals affected;
  4. The legitimate expectations of the person challenging the decision; and
  5. The choices of procedure made by the agency itself.

The Court noted the decision to terminate Holtby was final and specific in nature. The process followed by the Board prior to making the decision included a written reprimand and a clear warning as to the consequences of not following the detailed instructions provided. With respect to legitimate expectations, the Court noted that Holtby took his chances in failing to follow the direction of the Board to communicate and cooperate with it in the face of the prior warning.

In all of the circumstances of the case, the Court found that any duty of notice and opportunity to be heard in this case would have been minimal and was met by the Board.

In addition, any conclusion as to the internal workings of the Board with respect to the issue of bias would be pure speculation. There was no compelling evidence before the Court that Holtby’s termination was anything other than the Board’s reaction to what it perceived as insubordinate and intransigent conduct. A reasonable apprehension of bias had therefore not been made out.

The petition was therefore dismissed.

To stay current with the new case law and emerging legal issues in this area, subscribe here.

Tags

Important Notice: The information contained in this Article is intended for general information purposes only and does not create a lawyer-client relationship. It is not intended as legal advice from Harper Grey LLP or the individual author(s), nor intended as a substitute for legal advice on any specific subject matter. Detailed legal counsel should be sought prior to undertaking any legal matter. The information contained in this Article is current to the last update and may change. Last Update: January 16, 2024.

Related

Monique Sever participated in International Legal Technology Association’s video titled “Diversity in eDiscovery: It’s No Longer a Man’s World”
Monique Sever participated in International Legal Technology Association’s video titled “Diversity in eDiscovery: It’s No Longer a Man’s World” Monique Sever participated in International Legal Technology Association’s video titled “Diversity in eDiscovery: It’s No Longer a Man’s World”
An individual board member may disclose confidential board information to their own lawyer on matters affecting them personally
An individual board member may disclose confidential board information to their own lawyer on matters affecting them personally An individual board member may disclose confidential board information to their own lawyer on matters affecting them personally
Rose Keith, KC authors quarterly Mediation Moment Column for Spring 2024 Edition of The Verdict
Rose Keith, KC authors quarterly Mediation Moment Column for Spring 2024 Edition of The Verdict Rose Keith, KC authors quarterly Mediation Moment Column for Spring 2024 Edition of The Verdict
Dan Reid interviewed by Law360 in article titled “B.C. strengthens information-sharing protections in child welfare legislation after court decision”
Dan Reid interviewed by Law360 in article titled “B.C. strengthens information-sharing protections in child welfare legislation after court decision” Dan Reid interviewed by Law360 in article titled “B.C. strengthens information-sharing protections in child welfare legislation after court decision”
Harper Grey proudly sponsors The Lawyer Show
Harper Grey proudly sponsors The Lawyer Show Harper Grey proudly sponsors The Lawyer Show Harper Grey proudly sponsors The Lawyer Show
Drew Lawrenson and Arjun Dhaliwal to attend NABOC Vancouver Conference
Drew Lawrenson and Arjun Dhaliwal to attend NABOC Vancouver Conference Drew Lawrenson and Arjun Dhaliwal to attend NABOC Vancouver Conference Drew Lawrenson and Arjun Dhaliwal to attend NABOC Vancouver Conference
Leyla Salmi to attend UBC’s 2024 Spring Graduation Ceremony as Science Alumni Representative
Leyla Salmi to attend UBC’s 2024 Spring Graduation Ceremony as Science Alumni Representative Leyla Salmi to attend UBC’s 2024 Spring Graduation Ceremony as Science Alumni Representative
Norm Streu discusses understanding the legal obligations of confidentiality with Business In Vancouver
Norm Streu discusses understanding the legal obligations of confidentiality with Business In Vancouver Norm Streu discusses understanding the legal obligations of confidentiality with Business In Vancouver
Articling student Zheng-Yi Ong attends 17th Annual FACL Ontario Conference and Gala
Articling student Zheng-Yi Ong attends 17th Annual FACL Ontario Conference and Gala Articling student Zheng-Yi Ong attends 17th Annual FACL Ontario Conference and Gala
Rachel Wood joins Harper Grey as an Associate
Rachel Wood joins Harper Grey as an Associate Rachel Wood joins Harper Grey as an Associate
Harper Grey to host Empowering Female Entrepreneurs: Business Basics Webinar
Harper Grey to host Empowering Female Entrepreneurs: Business Basics Webinar
Harper Grey Professional Regulation Group recognized as “Consistently Recommended” by 2024 Canadian Legal Lexpert Directory
Harper Grey Professional Regulation Group recognized as “Consistently Recommended” by 2024 Canadian Legal Lexpert Directory
2024 Kathy O’Donovan Award of Excellence
2024 Kathy O’Donovan Award of Excellence
TAG Alliances published article authored by Norm Streu
TAG Alliances published article authored by Norm Streu TAG Alliances published article authored by Norm Streu
Harper Grey continues to support West Coast LEAF Through Supporter Sponsorship of 2024 Equity Breakfast
Harper Grey continues to support West Coast LEAF Through Supporter Sponsorship of 2024 Equity Breakfast
arrow icon

Subscribe